The Rise and Fall of Pentaquarks in Experiments

Experimental evidence for and against the existence of pentaquarks has accumulated rapidly in the last three years. If they exist, they would be dramatic examples of hadronic states beyond our well-tested and successful particle models. The positive evidence suggests existence of baryonic objects with widths of at most a few MeV, some displaying exotic quantum numbers, such as baryons with strangeness S = +1. The non-observations of these states have often come from reaction channels very different from the positive evidence channels, making comparisons difficult. The situation has now been largely clarified, however, by high-statistics repetitions of the positive sightings, with the result that none of the positive sightings have been convincingly reproduced. The most recent unconfirmed positive sightings suffer again from low statistics and large backgrounds. It seems that a kind of “bandwagon” effect led to the overly-optimistic interpretation of numerous experiments in the earlier reports of exotic pentaquarks.